On 7 October 2026 the Lake District National Park Authority granted reserved matters consent for seven dwellings at the former St Annes Elleray School, Elleray, Windermere LA23 1AP, five local occupancy and two affordable.
Applicant Mr Berry of GGE Ltd can build to the layout fixed under outline permission 7/2021/5689, approved on 23 June 2022, on a wooded site beside the Elleray drive. For anyone renting or buying in Windermere, Policy 15 requires the first five dwellings on windfall sites to be local occupancy and any additional to be on-site affordable housing.
Three of the seven plots, including both affordable homes, still depend on access from a private road towards Orrest Head. Windermere and Bowness Town Council says it will not allow construction or permanent access across its land at Orrest Head Lane.
Officers treat the town council’s Orrest Head Lane dispute as outside planning control, according to the officer report. The Mail reported the reserved matters decision despite continued council opposition.
What was approved
The October 2026 officer report by area planner Paula Allen, agreed by Andrew Smith, describes four detached houses (one five-bedroom and three three-bedroom) and a terrace of three two-bedroom houses, including the affordable units. Plots 1 and 2 are three-storey with a study and a lift. Access matches outline: four houses via the existing drive by the lodge; the other three, including the affordable homes, from the private road towards Orrest Head.
Officers said the scheme would provide 85 per cent of dwellings (six of seven) as two- and three-bedroom homes, aligned with the April 2023 Strategic Housing and Economic Needs Assessment.

The town council objected to reserved matters. It cited public safety where access for three properties would meet the Miles Without Stiles accessible public footpath (public right of way FP 581024) and the loss of 16 trees compared with nine at outline. The applicant proposes planting 44 new trees. The Mail reported that the town council says replacement planting cannot replicate mature habitat lost.
The authority’s Trees and Woodlands Officer, quoted in the report, said: “Whilst it is encouraging to see that 44 trees are proposed for planting to enhance the woodland, it is considered that the species mix represents a more formal, ornamental landscape rather than the more informal woodland characteristic that is more akin to the nature of the site.”
What homes sell for nearby
Land Registry price paid records for postcode sector LA23 1 (Windermere sector 1), counted through September 2026 and from 23 June 2022 when outline consent was granted, show no new-build sales in the sector. There were 203 existing-home sales at a median of £380,000.
In the same sector and period, houses sold for a median of £491,238 across 102 sales and flats for a median of £230,000 across 67 sales. Among detached, terraced and semi-detached sales, 41 detached sales had a median of £875,000 and 61 terraced or semi-detached sales had a median of £380,000, which frames the kind of open-market prices neighbours may already be paying on Elleray and nearby streets.
The approved scheme is all houses, so those detached and terrace medians sit closest to the mix now fixed at the former school site, even though none of the seven plots has completed in the register yet.
The wider LA23 district recorded one new-build sale at a median of £222,500 in this window. Completed sales do not separately identify local-occupancy or affordable homes; the seven-dwelling St Annes Elleray scheme is not yet visible in these figures.
Windermere’s other LA23 sectors recorded a median of £385,000 across 494 existing-home sales in the same period, little above sector LA23 1.
Source: HM Land Registry Price Paid Data
Sector LA23 1 covers Elleray and the wooded approaches towards Orrest Head, where detached sales have drawn much higher medians than terrace and semi-detached stock elsewhere in the town.
Records lag by about two months, so the counts run through September 2026 rather than the week of the reserved matters decision. Pryce’s sold-price trend for Windermere shows how values across the town have moved over time in Land Registry records.
Earlier refusal and appeal
In July 2025 the authority refused full application 7/2025/5086 for five local-needs houses (four three-bedroom and one four-bedroom units) on grounds including tree protection and woodland restoration, housing size and mix, and design, according to the officer report.
Planning appeal 6004196 against that refusal was dismissed on 14 May 2026 by Inspector Harrison F under written representations. The inspector found that, given the proposal was in the Lake District National Park, the Lake District World Heritage Site and the Windermere conservation area, the proposal would be “unduly harmful to the character and appearance of the area, including trees”, as reported by The Westmorland Gazette.
On size for local needs, the inspector said: “despite the generous scale of the proposed dwellings, there is no clear evidence that the internal floor space or configuration of the accommodation of the proposed dwellings would make them unsuitable for local needs.” The Westmorland Gazette reported the inspector’s view that white render on five dwellings “would draw the eye and appear discordant when compared to the prevailing use of stone and more balanced mix of traditional materials along Church Street.”
The October 2026 reserved matters decision fixes appearance, layout, scale and landscaping for the original seven-home mix under outline permission, not the refused five-house scheme.
What happens next
Building can proceed only in line with conditioned plans, including Rev E elevations from April 2026 and further planting approvals. Outline permission still requires an approved surface water drainage scheme before commencement. The town council’s refusal to allow access across its Orrest Head Lane land remains unresolved outside planning control, according to officers.
