Skip to content

Planning

Hertsmere refuses 700 Compass Park homes in Bushey over £7.6m school bill

Councillors rejected Compass Park on green-belt farmland after developers refused Hertfordshire County Council's £7.6 million secondary-school levy.

Property photograph
Open fields north of Farm Way at Bushey, Hertfordshire, in 2019. Wikimedia Commons

Hertsmere Borough Council refused permission for 700 homes at Compass Park, Bushey, north of Farm Way, according to BBC News. The green-belt farmland site lies on the northern edge of Bushey.

Councillors also cited harm to the green belt and the loss of farmland on the site between Little Bushey Lane and Hayfield Close. Officers said the scheme fails to secure the financial contribution considered necessary to mitigate additional secondary education demand, according to the BBC.

Developers agreed £7,063,396 for primary education plus school land and £1,186,295 for Breakspeare School SEND places but refused £7,596,369 for secondary school places, leaving the county’s secondary bill unpaid. They dispute the secondary figure, saying surplus places already exist.

Primary yes, secondary no

The planning committee voted 11 to 1 to refuse on 5 November, according to The Borehamwood Post.

Liberal Democrat councillor Miles Ponder told councillors: “These are documented infrastructure concerns, they’re not speculations. We cannot build hundreds of homes and simply hope that the essential infrastructure will catch up.”

Sam Calder, representing the developers at the planning meeting:

“After six months of dialogue, the County Council continues to seek funds to expand the secondary network. Its justification is that this is needed to meet future demand from outside Hertsmere, namely Watford. Compass Park cannot reasonably be required to fund education needs arising elsewhere.”

Where new homes have dried up

In WD23 2, the postcode sector nearest Compass Park, Land Registry records show new-build homes made up 20 per cent of 444 sales in 2016–2018 and 2 per cent of 391 sales in 2022–2024. That fall preceded the committee’s decision on a scheme that would have added hundreds of new homes on farmland the council said it could not release without a full education settlement.

In Bushey, sold prices in October 2025–September 2026 had a median of £550,000 across 308 sales, with one new-build sale, though September 2026 sales are incomplete. Hertsmere’s median was £530,000 on 1,078 sales in the same period, with one new-build sale.

Across the East of England the median was £370,000 on 78,801 sales, with new builds making up 2 per cent of sales. Across England the median was £285,000 on 676,259 sales, with new builds making up 2 per cent of sales.

New-build share of WD23 2 sales fell from 20 per cent of 444 to 2 per cent of 391

Source: HM Land Registry Price Paid Data

Far short of the homes required

Officers told councillors Hertsmere’s housing land supply is substantially below five years. The 2025 Housing Delivery Test found the borough built 26 per cent of the homes it needed over three years, according to The Borehamwood Post.

Hill Group and Clarion said Hertsmere has less than one year’s housing land supply, and Compass Park would have helped address that need by delivering 700 much-needed homes. The scheme included up to 700 homes, half affordable, and a 70-bed care home.

The site was dropped from the current local plan after a draft allocation in 2021. The council notified 2,168 residents and recorded 602 objections among 612 comments on the application.

Twenty-one days for the minister

Because the scheme covers more than 150 homes, Hertsmere must consult the Secretary of State for 21 days before issuing a formal refusal notice. The application could be called in, and the applicants can appeal to the Planning Inspectorate.