Skip to content

Planning

150-home outline plan on green belt south of Smithy Close in Pannal

Half the homes on playing fields and recreation ground in Pannal would be affordable. North Yorkshire Council has not set a date to decide.

A wide green field bordered by autumn trees at the junction of Harrogate Road (A61) and John Metcalf Way in Pannal.
Open land beside the A61 at Pannal in 2022, on the edge of the area where Forward Investments LLP proposes up to 150 homes. habiloid, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Harrogate Advertiser reported in September 2026 that Forward Investments LLP has submitted an outline application for up to 150 homes on land south of Smithy Close in Pannal, west of Thirkhill Drive.

The land sits beside the A61 and includes three agricultural fields and an existing recreation ground with two playing fields, a car park and a play area. For people who use those pitches or live on Smithy Close and Thirkhill Drive, the scheme would replace open green belt with housing while the council weighs Harrogate’s housing land shortfall against green-belt protection.

The planning statement says the former Harrogate district currently has just 2.2 years of deliverable housing land, against the five-year supply required by national policy. It puts the shortfall at 5,492 homes needed over five years including the relevant buffer, against a deliverable supply of 3,111 properties.

Open this area on the map
Former Dunlopillo site, Pannal

What was applied for

The outline application could provide up to 150 properties alongside new public open space, ecological habitat and landscaping. The applicant proposes 50 per cent affordable housing, above the 40 per cent normally required for greenfield sites.

Almost half of the site, around 3.7 hectares, would be green infrastructure, including an enhanced community park, an enlarged play area, new paths, planting and green corridors. Vehicle access would be from Thirkhill Drive. The application states Pannal railway station would be within an 800-metre walk of all the new homes.

The undeveloped part of the site is within the green belt and the site is outside Pannal’s development limits. Your Harrogate reported that the applicant argues the land meets the Government’s definition of grey belt because it does not strongly contribute to several of the purposes of the green belt.

The Harrogate Advertiser and Your Harrogate have both framed the submission around what would be lost if the council releases the land: green belt, playing pitches and recreation space used by people in Pannal, set against the applicant’s case that Harrogate needs more deliverable sites. The outline does not settle that argument; it asks the council to weigh housing need against those open uses.

BBC News said on 15 September 2026 the developer describes the proposals as the third phase of development around the former Dunlopillo site, following earlier housing, a care home and commercial development. The outline would extend building beyond Pannal’s development limit on land that has been industrial and recreational, with green-belt boundaries still wrapping much of the village.

Double railway tracks curving through frosty fields near Pannal, with an industrial building visible in the distance.
The Leeds–Harrogate line near Pannal in 2012, beside the former Dunlopillo factory land now earmarked for housing. John Sparshatt, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

What homes sell for in HG3

Land Registry records for HG3, which covers Pannal and surrounding villages, show how new-build sales compare with existing homes nearby. They cannot be tied to the former Dunlopillo site or named streets alone, and affordable homes often do not appear as open-market sales in this dataset. The Price Paid Data lag by about two months, so recent months are not yet complete in the public record.

Across 2022 to 2024, the median price paid for a new-build home in HG3 was £417,500 across 444 sales. Existing homes in the same postcode district sold for a median of £380,000 across 1,385 sales in that period. New-build homes made up about a quarter of HG3 sales in 2022 to 2024, up from roughly a sixth of sales in 2017 to 2019.

Median price paid for new build versus existing homes, HG3, 2022 to 2024

Source: HM Land Registry Price Paid Data

The median for new builds in HG3 was about 5 per cent lower in 2022 to 2024 than in 2017 to 2019, when it stood at £439,995 across 294 sales.

Pannal’s recorded sold-price trend on Pryce tracks how prices paid in the village’s HG3 market have moved on those Land Registry sales over time, for readers weighing nearby values against the proposed scheme.

Flats accounted for a small share of HG3 sales in 2022 to 2024, at 71 homes sold, down from 80 in 2017 to 2019. Most recorded transactions in the district remain houses, which matches the type of homes implied by a 150-home outline on fields and recreation land beside the A61.

What happens next

North Yorkshire Council has not set a date to determine the outline application. If the council approves the scheme in principle, layout, scale, affordable housing detail and recreation provision would follow through reserved matters applications and further consultation.